Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The World's Largest Rewrite: The First and Probably Last Rhinoceros-Based Fire Suppression System

What is this? The whole series is here, and the first post explaining what is going on is here.

 #111: Spectre. The spectre is just a tankier wraith. It has been a rough couple of decades for the spectres. As of 5E, they've been demoted to the low-challenge-rating spawn that wraiths spit out when they drain someone to death.

We can use the Monster Overhaul’s catch-all ghost category to expand our spectres. They cannot cross running water, or objects painted to resemble water. So water, routed by the gargoyles, is used to contain them. They’re prisoners here because no one knows how to banish them.

#96: Rhagodessa. Archanids with suckers on their legs that grab prey to set up an automatic bite on the next turn. We can return to the giant spider Overhaul entry again to spice these up. One of the stranger spider variants there are crafting spiders, with “human hands, pale human-like faces. As smart as most people, but fickle and ascetic.” The dungeon has plenty of monstrous animals, so adding another intelligent creature as a prisoner type is appealing. 

#13: Buccaneer. The buccaneer stat block itself is not interesting; they are essentially the same as many of the other 1 HD humans we’ve already covered. As with many of those other human stat blocks, the entry is primarily a tool for creating a wilderness/town faction, moreso than stats for a dungeon encounter.

Rolling there, we get four small galleys patrolling the coastal waters, each crewed by 20 buccaneers. A couple 4th level lieutenants are present; each ship is captained by a 7th level fighter; and we have a fleet commander who is a 9th level fighter. They also have an 8th-level cleric. They have maps to buried treasure and have a lawless, fortified pirate haven nearby. 

The Overhaul gives us extra detail to work with. The ships are named The Venture, Spearheart, Aurora, and The Albatross. Several have seen better times, but the fleet commander’s ship is freshly painted. They seek the seaglass staff, a legendary piratical artifact. The fleet commander is Reginald Hooke, who has an “untrustworthy parrot”! Clearly a spy for the octopus cult. Their cleric is Godeke Dire, who plays the fiddle.

#125: Tyrannosaurus Rex. This rounds out the lost world theme. The stat block is what you would expect. The most interesting thing there is that they have treasure type “V x 3”; the only other creature with that treasure type is the noble. Is this a joke, referencing that the t-rex as the “king” of dinosaurs? The Overhaul gives a save-or-die on a bite dealing more than 10 damage, which is a nice way to drive home its deadliness.

#91: Pirate. Statistically almost identical to buccaneers, but chaotic instead of neutral. This group has five small galleys with 40 crew each. We also have a whole mess of 4th and 5th level pirates, and two 8th-level pirates leading the fleet. Those leaders are Khadiga (flat pancake face) and Essafah (stump-fingered). The pirates outnumber the buccaneers, but their two leaders are vying for control of the fleet, and regularly try to betray each other, so they aren't unified enough to wipe out their bucaneer rivals. All of these pirates and buccaneers are drawn here by legends suggesting that the seaglass staff is held within the prison dungeon. Whether this is true or is merely octopus cult propaganda remains to be seen. 


An animated gif of a walking rhinoceros, made out of simple block shapes

#118: Titanothere. Huge, peaceful, lost world rhinoceros relatives. The Overhaul directs us to rhinoceros, which thankfully has a legendary abilities table. It is troubled by parasites, and cleaning its skin is the only way to get the normally peaceful creatures to calm down and stop trampling people. 

#8: Berserker. The Overhaul’s barbarian entry does double duty here. These berserkers can break weapons or shatter armor as a feat of strength. They want rare beasts, which explains why they would be in the prison, to seek out those lost world beasts. They are led by Tunbeard, who collects unusual teeth. Fits with the “rare beasts” hobby. 

This group has the opposite temperament of our barbarians. As with buccaneers and pirates, the easiest way to create separation between synonyms is to make them rivals or ideological foes.

#44: Giant. The same canonical big six that appear in modern D&D. The Overhaul splits them into giants (hill, stone, as well as giantkin like the ettin and cyclops) and noble giants (storm, cloud, frost, fire, and some stranger examples). There’s even an entry for boneless giants, which must be a reference to Deep Carbon Observatory.

The Overhaul’s “Why Fight These Giants” table tells us they “roasted our best diplomat alive.” That suggests a prisoner. Rolling some more, we get a forest giant, mossy, with antlers. Perhaps a forest guardian, associated with our treants and dryads atop the prison. And the diplomat was the celestial representative who first came to bargain over the opening of the prison. And their death made the forest giant one of the very first inmates.

#97: Rhinoceros. Both normal and wooly varieties, and the latter is a lost world resident. But distinct from a Titanothere! Somehow! Surely this bestiary needed two ancient rhinoceros-type creatures. For some reason. 

We return to the Overhaul’s rhinoceros entry. I appreciate how the Overhaul handles several of the ordinary beasts by giving them “legendary” abilities. These could be literal abilities in a high-magic game; or the mark of a paragon of that animal type; or merely local rumors that serve as hooks and detail for the setting. This gives some depth to entries that otherwise boil down to “use bears plus poison/charge/swallow/etc.” for many real-world animals.

Rolling there, we learn that a rhinoceros “tramples out fires wherever they [find] them, not from fear but from duty.” That’s unexpected. We’ve already discussed the problem of fire in the dungeon, particularly because the glass hounds starting invisible fires. A rhinoceros can smell those fires and put them out before they spread. They’re here to help. That just might not be obvious to a terrified party when a rhinoceros fire brigade comes barreling down a dungeon corridor.

#128: Veteran. Completing the PC-classes-as-monster-entries, the veterans are low-level fighters, presumably soldiers. Returning to the Overhaul’s mercenary entry, we see that they have a “false reputation for cruelty.” They can’t fight today because “the enemy made us a better offer.” So they’re traitors. Against who? Remember that the orcs are on their way to trash the prison. These veterans have been hired to fight the orcs, but have decided (probably correctly) that whoever has commissioned them isn’t a good bet to actually pay, and they’re better off finding a way to get rich quick before the orcs arrive.




The end is near. One more post wraps up this series.  

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

The 3x3 Language Grid: Dialect, Formal, Technical; Spoken, Written, Symbolic

The 3x3 alignment grid has a certain elegance to it. While I do not like the good-evil axis of D&D’s traditional grid, I appreciate the dynamics of the grid itself. 

The average person can remember something like 3-9 items on a list, depending on which research on the topic you find most compelling. A 3x3 grid is actually closer to the low end, because you don't really need to remember all nine things. If you can remember four things – good, evil, chaos, and law – you can extrapolate all the categories, because they are implicitly obvious if you remember how they intersect. 

Indeed, you see this grid come up in the simplest of games, as well as in schemes beyond alignment that also present categories defined by intersecting criteria.

What if we used a 3x3 grid for something besides alignment? Something like a TTRPG language? 

Consider a language that looked like this:


Dialect Formal Technical
Spoken Y Y N
Written N Y Y
Symbolic N N N


This language, when spoken aloud, has informal and formal tenses, terms, or word-forms. Written language is reserved for formal or technical subjects only, typical of societies with low enough literacy that only sufficiently “important” things are written down. The language eschews symbols.

This could be a typical medieval human society. People in court speak differently than ordinary folk. Written language is reserved for priests and certain other learned parties.

Now imagine a stranger example. 


Dialect Formal Technical
Spoken Y N Y
Written Y N Y
Symbolic N N Y


This is a society with no formal-tense language at all. Casual language is similar when spoken or written, but symbols are reserved for technical subjects.

This could be the language of a group of egalitarian engineers or wizards. Technical language spreads across all available domains, but their other speaking and writing is dialectic.

Let’s do one more.


Dialect Formal Technical
Spoken N Y Y
Written N N N
Symbolic Y Y N


Weird! Symbols capture a looseness and informality that is not permitted elsewhere. Spoken language is reserved for only formal and technical subjects. There is no writing at all.

This culture’s commitment to its oral history for formal and technical subjects has incentivized its people to use symbols to capture any subject that is not “important enough” to be transmitted orally. This would be a very strange and counter-intuitive society for someone to interact with; speaking to them about anything but the most critical matters could be forbidden, even offensive, as they frantically try to steer the outsider into symbology.


A 19th century drawing of a man surrounded by numbered ribbons, pointing to the right



Tuesday, November 3, 2026

The World's Largest Rewrite: Stupid Sprite Tricks, Monsters Ate My Pants, Uncle Boonmee Who Can Recall His Past Delves

The whole series is here, and the first post explaining what is going on is here.

A note on links: Since the beginning, these posts have included links to OSE monster entries. Necrotic Gnome appears to be overhauling their site as part of a 2026 streamlining of the OSE collection (would have been nice if old links had redirected to the new ones, but I'm not going to look a gift SRD in the mouth). If I have time I may go back and fix all these links, but until I do, you can go here and see the OSE monster list.

A further note on the monster list: During the late summer of 2026, while I was editing the final posts in this series, OSE significantly revised its lists of monsters. Great for OSE's continued development as a system, but this exercise will stick to the old, simple, B/X list from our beginning post; I'm not going to go back and attempt to determine the placement of creatures such as the Tree-Beast of Tarktuktulak.

 #113: Sprite. Quite similar to pixies, which we already covered as the “boring” ones. Sprites in OSE have a bit more to work with. Groups of five or more can curse someone, and they prank people instead of killing them, even after the offending party has attacked them. So the pixies are innocently trapped in the prison, while the sprites are intentionally making mischief. Tapping the Monster Overhaul again, we get a fly theme, and they’re drawing rude pictures. So they’re drawing graffiti all over the dungeon. They’re probably going to prank and ridicule PCs, but they could also be useful informants. Anyone willing to pull a suitably outrageous prank on a powerful monster could earn their friendship. Hm…

#17: Carcass Crawler. Why does OSE have an off-brand carrion crawler, but not equivalent rebranded monsters for the mindflayer and the beholder? Other retroclone and old-school/new-school systems are not shy about doing their own legally distinct versions of trademarked WotC monsters.

As an encounter, the OSE crawler is either trivial or a TPK. It doesn’t actually do any damage, and can only eat someone if “left in peace.” But it can attack eight times per round, and paralyzes people for 2d4 turns (on average, 50 minutes). PCs kiting it and peppering it with arrows can deal with it easily. A group surprised by it (or foolishly entering melee by choice) is asking for carcassification.

The Overhaul redirects to the monstrous vermin entry, which includes a carrion caterpillar that hits all the same beats. Lets treat the caterpillar aspect as literal and assume that this is the larval form of another monster. I already made a monstrous caterpillar, so I can just steal from myself. Adding the paralysis is nice. Imagine a caterpillar that paralyzes your entire party, eats your clothes off your body while you lie there helplessly, and then leaves you behind, naked but uninjured. TPK (total pants kill).

#2: Ape, White. The most confusing part of the OSE entry is the phrase “gorilla-like apes.” Gorillas… are apes? Anyway, they’re herbivorous, and enemies of our cavemen. Neanderthals hate this one weird ape.

Rolling on the Overhaul table, we get “retain hazy memories of their past lives as villagers, and sometimes watch and protect their descendants.” Is this an Uncle Boonmee situation? It certainly spices up an otherwise generic ape encounter. Perhaps the apes are the descendants of a village that was displaced for the construction of the prison. They would be a sympathetic faction, but highly mysterious, spiritual, and decidedly non-material. The neanderthals hate them due to a (probably misplaced) trust in the prison builders, who displaced the white apes when the complex was built. 

#121: Treant. With the carcass crawler I mentioned the monsters that are legally distinct adaptations of WotC monsters; it is worth remembering that D&D from its beginning has likewise had monsters who were in turn borrowed from elsewhere.

The treant is a straightforward protector of nature, and the relatively recent redirection of the river into the dungeon provides a pretty easy basis for them to be agitated. These treants probably dwell among the dryads we previously learned about, but are further removed from the prison builders. WIth their very slow sense of the progression of human-scale events, they may only be dimly aware of the prison at all.

#73: Medium. If you’re wondering why OSE has no entries for “wizard” or “mage” but includes a “medium” entry, it is because that is the title for a novice magic-user. This was actually true of several previous entries, like the acolyte.

The Overhaul includes a lavish five pages for wizards. So we have a trio of junior wizards – Shorth, Zephiros, and Claar – wandering around in this dungeon. Why are they here? Their notable spells are (respectively) Silence, Vertigo, and Glittergust. Shorth has a headless, hairless lemur as a familiar. Zephiors has a wand of knock/lock (quite handy in a prison). Claar is a teaching assistant at Blackspine, their wizarding school, so they are probably boss the two undergrads around. Their area of study is hallucinations! For “why is this wizard in the dungeon” we get “retracing the steps of their mentor,” which fits. Their mentor is (or is rumored to be) a prisoner here. 

 

An animated gif from the TV show Adventure Time, depicting various wizards from the show linking arms in a magical circle


#88: Orc. I have hundreds of words in my blog post drafts on orcs, racism, and associated RPG discourse. When I first read the Overhaul and looked up the orc entry, I learned that Skerples had covered the core of what I wanted to say better in a section on the orc page titled “The Problem of Evil,” essentially saying that orcs can be inherently evil, or they can be people like other creatures, but these two categories can’t be mixed. I believe that modern D&D keeps stepping on this rake because there is no coherent sense of this distinction.

For purposes of our current use-case, the orcs are harbingers of an invasion. Smoke on the horizon has signaled their approach. They can taste blood to learn secrets. Their prize tools are siege engines. They (apparently) seek to destroy the local religion.

So the orcs are here to undo the work of the celestial prison builders. Only a few patrols are present at the start of the scenario, but more appear, eventually displacing the external factions and using their siegeworks to dig into the prison. This provides a clock on a campaign set in the prison. They are not monsters that can be realistically beaten, but a force of nature that will eventually destroy the prison.

The Overhaul’s framing of orcs is rooted in rumors and suspicion, so there’s a strong chance that their motivation is somewhat different than what's described above. They may even prove to be a surprisingly pragmatic faction to deal with; more so than many of the prisoners and wardens, anyway.

#67: Living Statue. I think the classic animated statue has lost ground over D&D’s edition to the golems, with which it shares a lot in common. We can use the lawful crystal statue as a prison guardian. Their programmatic behavior means they serve faithfully, but they are inflexible and predictable, so the inmates are gradually isolating and destroying them. 

#48: Golem. Convenient to do these two back to back. I was surprised to see how much OSE’s golem entry differs from the the standard lineup that is pretty familiar in modern D&D: flesh (Frankensteinned), clay (closest to the original idea of the golem), stone (much more like OSE’s living statue), and iron (magical robot). OSE instead includes amber (animal-shaped tracker), bone (four-armed, non-undead), bronze (giant-sized, heated by fire within) and wood (small and simple).

Amber makes the most sense for our prison, but we already have an escaped-prisoner-tracking monster, so we’ll pick the bronze golem because it is the weirdest.

#89: Owl Bear. The D&D classic. For all of its brand recognition, it is mechanically interchangeable with a non-owl bear, a problem that continues up through modern D&D, where none of its history in the game makes it an interesting monster. Others have blogged about what a missed opportunity owlbears are, and how they could be more interesting.

Our Overhaul-informed leaves “dry log-sized pellets full of bones” and its mood of madness is “manic digging.” We already have burrowing monsters well-represented, but we could place the owlbear in the treant/dryad forest on top of the prison, and their dig sites could be dangerous but useful points of access to the upper parts of the prison. 

#112: Spider, Giant. Another classic. OSE has black widow (deadly poison), crab (camouflage), and tarantella (uncontrollable dancing). Choosing randomly, we get the last one. The Overhaul has armor as “if illuminated, as leather. In darkness, as plate+shield.” I love details like this that demonstrate how the Overhaul is willing to break from old-school orthodoxy when there’s a more interesting option. We’ll add extensive web spinning as a feature.

We’re in the home stretch. Just one more post after this, and we will be done with the entire OSE bestiary.

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Taste-Testing D&D Potion Identification Methods

Potions are the “most accessible” magic items in the world of fantasy RPGs. Holy revengers, staves of powerfulness, and hammers of the dwarvensort are limited to particular types of characters. But anyone – from a veteran adventurer to the lowliest hireling to a Victorian girl lost in a wondrous land – can drink a mysterious liquid and just see what happens.

How PCs determine what exactly a potion does is a vague-gestures-and-shrugs exercise for some dungeon fantasy systems. The 5E (2014) DMG says that “...a little taste is enough to tell the taster what the potion does.” OSE is more guarded, stating that “A potion may be identified by sipping a small amount. It is difficult to identify potions purely by smell or taste, as even potions with the same effect are not alike.” Worlds Without Number has a few layers of possible interpretation wrapped around the taste-test-as-clue rule. Knave 2E keeps it simple: “A drop of a potion gives a clue as to its effects.” The AD&D DMG gives a typically adversarial framing, suggesting that the DM should “add a few different sorts of potions, both helpful and harmful, of such nature as to cause difficulties in identification.”

A 5E potion is a resource. An OSE potion is a risk. A WWN potion is a downtime skill challenge. A Knave potion is a mystery. An AD&D potion is a challenge.


An animated gif displaying eight brightly colored potions, bubbling and vibrating with obvious magical energy

How can we make potions a puzzle that preserve mystery but reward experimentation and attention to detail? Consider a list of 20 typical fantasy potions, with textures and colors drawn from Knave 2E’s random tables.

Potion of Animal Friendship Churning Salmon
Potion of Clairvoyance Churning Dove Gray
Potion of Darkvision Flakes Dove Gray
Potion of Delusion Flakes Dove Gray
Potion of Diminution Sediment Dove Gray
Potion of Fire Resistance Sediment Salmon
Potion of Flying Viscid Electric Blue
Potion of Gaseous Form Bubbling Moss Green
Potion of Giant Strength Flakes Moss Green
Potion of Growth Viscid Moss Green
Potion of Healing Churning Salmon
Potion of Heroism Churning Salmon
Potion of Invisibility Sediment Opalescent
Potion of Madness Bubbling Electric Blue
Potion of Petrification Flakes Opalescent
Potion of Poison Viscid Moss Green
Potion of Speed Bubbling Electric Blue
Potion of Stone Skin Sediment Opalescent
Potion of Transformation Viscid Opalescent
Potion of Water Breathing Bubbling Electric Blue

Some textures and colors seem to communicate the vibe of a particular potion clearly. Some combinations are unique. Others appear to be the same, but are not. Of course the viscid, moss-green potion is poison… but it could also be a potion of growth.

Players can engage with this as a gamble (drink it and see what happens) or as a puzzle (can we infer things about its nature by where it was found) or as a goal (we can spend money in town to have the alchemist identify these with certainty). 

Knave 2E has a rule that succeeding on a check by 10 or more to create a potion provides a recipe and eliminates the need for further checks. The same sort of logic could apply to potion identification; clear a certain threshold, whether mechanical or diegetic, and the "mystery" of a particular potion's nature is not interesting any more; just give PCs the information after that point. 

The table above is a deliberately light touch, but you could be more formulaic about it if you want to emphasize challenge and mystery. This could absolutely be a logic grid puzzle, where color aligns with school of magic and taste aligns with effect. Assuming certain combinations have fixed meanings, the PCs could intuit the nature of unknown potions as they experiment with the ones they have already found. How much formulaic rigor we want to apply depends on the players’ interest in engaging with these factors, and how central potions are to our game.

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Veins of the Earth is (also) a Mothership Bestiary

Veins of the Earth (VotE henceforth) is an old-school take on the Underdark, published in 2017 by Patrick Stuart. Work on a remastered version is currently underway. Stuart's fictional worlds are sharply realized and evocative, but I have found it difficult to bring those worlds to the table, precisely because they are so unique and sometimes difficult to fit into a game that is not built around them.

I have used bits and pieces of VotE in the past, but never incorporated all of its tools into my games. The vibe is pretty dark, bordering on survival horror, like the movie The Descent extrapolated out into a whole underground world. So I have struggled to add a lot of VotE's best elements to my dungeon fantasy games.

But VotE is not just a dungeon fantasy bestiary. The horror? The cold logic of its world? The sense of deep time? Could that work in another system that I've been running lately? A system like Mothership?

To illustrate, I have randomly chosen a few VotE monsters and described how they could appear in a Mothership game. Suggested stat blocks refer to Unconfirmed Contact Reports (UCR), the Mothership bestiary.

Fossil Vampire

Entombed, ancient vampires, gone mad from confinement, hungry for blood they can no longer digest. This one needs essentially no tailoring. VotE’s description of an actual strata of buried vampire paleo-horror is a ready-made Mothership scenario.

You could have it take place on a dry desert planet, and model the fossil vampires as thirsty not just for blood, but for any source of moisture, desiccating their victims into husks. Perhaps the planet has an irregular day/night cycle, due to axial tilt, a binary star system, or some other stellar effect. If the characters can figure out how the day/night cycle works, they can use that against the vampires.

For swarms of fossil vampires, exploding out of an exposed seam of vampire sediment, use the UCR’s generic swarm stat block. If any crew member is overwhelmed three-to-one or more by these creatures, they are dehydrated (disadvantage on all rolls, per the food & water rules in the Player’s Survival Guide (p. 32.5). Any successive hit from a swarm of vampires to an already-dehydrated character is an automatic wound.

For a different style of vampire scenario, use the generic hunter stat block (or the stats for the Belladonnas) and deploy it in a classic Alien “it is loose on the ship” scenario. Same dehydration ability. It will also “drink” ship water supplies, liquid fuel, pseudomilk, and any other liquid it can find.

Stormsheep

Glassy, conductive things, spiky like sea urchins, moving by instinct, seeking electricity and conductive metals. Once again, here is a monster that can be dropped into a Mothership game with almost no tailoring. 

Imagine a routine ore transport job. The ore is mostly lead, but there are chunks of copper mixed in with the lead, and dormant stormsheep are sleeping within the copper. Agitated by the electrical field of the crew’s ship during a warp jump, the stormsheep awaken and begin to escape their leaden prison. 


The stormsheep from Veins of the Earth, a central white mass floating in darkness with thin white appendages sticking out


The crew becomes aware of them at first due to minor electrical malfunctions. This can play out like a Star Trek episode, where something that initially appears to be a mundane ship maintenance issue hints at a bigger problem. This kind of scenario can organically engage first the teamsters, then the scientists and androids, and finally the marines, as the problem matriculates from annoyance to mystery to danger.

Stormsheep can interact catastrophically with the electrical field of the brain. Body save or brain damage (disadvantage at one randomly chosen skill). Advanced anti-epilepsy implants can fix this condition, but they’re not cheap. The stormsheep are also harmed by this contact, as human thoughts stagger and madden them. So stormsheep as a threat present a different look than the typical monster that just wants to consume the crew; the encounter is mutually disastrous for the crew and the stormsheep.

Perhaps the stormsheep can be lured out of the ship with a uniquely conductive metal or a similarly ingenuous plan. But the simplest way to deal with it – not the most ethical, but the most direct – is to throw people at it until the conflicting memories of their fried synapses scramble the stormsheep until they can be safely jettisoned.

Silichominids

I want to quote from this VotE entry to really drive home how much industrial language and modern imagery is baked into what is ostensibly a fantasy bestiary. A silichominid has “the smell of plastic landfills”; an “atom-reactor hatewail”; flesh “woven from beryllium and aluminum." These are silicon-based creatures wearing “exo-suits” to explore what they perceive as a hostile environment. 

While the stormsheep are dangerous because they don’t realize electricity from human neurons is not OK to eat, the silichominids are dangerous because carbon-based life is a complete mystery to them. VotE says “Imagine sheltered first-world tourists wandering around a refugee camp.” Their touch burns. Everything that is natural and good to them is toxic and deadly to humans. The opposite is true, and if their suits are ruptured, it is like a small dirty nuke going off. Think about all the sci-fi stories that involve humans harming or destroying alien life due to various anthropocentric assumptions, then turn those around. When the Silichominids show up, the crew is on the receiving end of a Stanisław Lem story.

Use the brute stat block from UCR, with an extra 4d10 damage at close range from the explosion if its suit is ruptured.


Tuesday, October 13, 2026

The World's Largest Rewrite: Octo-Cultists, Bug Ecology, Tortoise Tsar

Previous posts in this series are here if you want to try to understand what is going on here. On to the monsters.

#3: Bandit. Whereas OSE brigands are fighter-coded ruffians, the bandits are the thief-derived scoundrels. Going back to the Overhaul mercenary entry, we learn that their mission is to bulk up their numbers. So they’re here at the prison to recruit anyone (or anything) who is close to escaping, particularly if their help indebts the creature to them. In contrast to the loud and obvious brigand group, these bandits are keeping a low profile. 

The OSE entry notes they can have a leader of 2nd level or higher (any human class). Rolling randomly, we get magic-user. Using the Overhaul’s adventurer table we get “Smith M. Ledgermain,” which is sounds like a wizard forced to make up a fake name on the spot. He has a fancy feathered hat, is a spy, and has a hypnotic silver hand mirror. OK, so the bandits are here to recruit, but Ledgermain is also after a person of interest within the prison; probably someone he wants to kill. His bandit gang doesn’t know about this secret objective.

#124: Troll. The Overhaul entry gives us some good material to add around the classic vanilla OSE block. Apparently people call these trolls “night howlers.” While I don’t have any issue with players metagaming a troll encounter (because metagaming is good gaming), there’s an extra challenge if the DM never says the word “troll.” It requires the players to make the connection in order to gain the advantage. These troll pa-troll-ees (maybe? idk) specialize in “tragic ransoms.” They’re rubberized, so they can squeeze under some of the prison doors. Probably some kind of acid runoff from the black dragon is helping to keep them imprisoned. And of course these trolls are the source of our thouls.

#68: Lizard, Giant. Picking randomly we get the horned chameleon, who has a sticky tongue-grab attack, camouflage, and a knock-down tail attack. That’s plenty of action for a brute like this. We’ll treat these as steeds and guardians for our trepan lizards, who clearly need some muscle to support their brainy rule.

#1: Acolyte. There are seven of them, so they get a third-level leader. The Overhaul sends us to the cultist entry, where we learn that they lair in an ancient amphitheater, and their dark purpose is the manipulation of political events. Maybe their leader is Smith M. Ledgermain’s target? 

These cultists want to complete a ritual to summon an obedient avatar of their god, and the ritual requires crystals, bone, and ash, so they’re trying to collect those items within the dungeon. Apparently they follow Garnsolex the Kraken! Perhaps Garnsolex is one of those giant intelligent octopi we heard about earlier. Again using the Overhaul’s adventurer table to flesh out the acolyte's leader, we learn they are Ren Cullowsong, who has an octoparrot advisor. Perfect.

#129: Warp Beast. This is OSE’s non-trademark-infringing displacer beast. As previously mentioned, they hate -- and are hated in turn -- by blink dogs. The Overhaul, in yet another taxonomic choice I appreciate and agree with, groups both displacer beasts and blink dogs under the category of “shivered beast,” a catch-all for creatures that can violate Euclidian reality in some way. 

The entry includes a “displaced cat” to meet the demand for vanilla displacer beasts, but I’m more interested in one of the novel types from the shivered beast variant table. Choosing randomly, I get the underdog, a cunning lizard-hound that can appear or disappear under any unobserved space. It experiences gravity in an inverted way, and has a double climb speed. I like this as an imprisoned creature that is trying to escape, but is also the principal foe of the blink dogs.


An animated gif depicting the demon cat from the TV show Adventure Time, has a displacer-beast-like aesthetic


#98: Robber Fly. Three-foot long flies that hunt killer bees. Once again, the implied ecosystem is interesting. They hunt killer bees and are immune to their venom. They are in turn preyed on by giant tiger beetles. Our intelligent factions are going to want to exploit robber flies too, because they can kill bees, which control the valuable honey. Not every monster needs to be part of an ecological chain like this, but done in moderation, it really improves what could be “just another giant bug” in a vacuum. 

#66: Leech, Giant. Speaking of giant bugs... here's the leeches. While OSE giant leeches have six times as many hit dice as stirges, they only drain at twice the rate. The Overhaul gives us a few entries to borrow from, including marine worm. The lamprey variant heals when it bites. That works for me.

#33: Dryad. Dryads must stay near their trees, so they're helpful to the celestials as "guardians" who won't just leave. Perhaps the prison builders enticed them to move here by promising to protect their trees. They’ve charmed both intruders and prison escapees and are becoming increasingly paranoid as the local situation gets worse. One or more of the dryads is injured and that’s why the unicorn is here.

#43: Ghoul. I considered creating a ghoul that is closer to the ghūl origins of the term (a shapeshifting “demon,” something like a djinni), but I think it would require a deeper study of the mythology to do it justice. For now, we will stick with the familiar fantasy genre representation of the ghoul as a corpse-eating, paralysis-inducing undead creature. Monster Overhaul, take the wheel.

The ghouls’ corpse acquisition scheme is a massive tunnel collapse. Perhaps they’re digging under the prison, hoping to undermine sections of the prison and feast upon the prisoners. No one will miss those terrible prisoners, right? The ghouls will even parlay with the PCs, seeking information about the greatest concentrations of sapient creatures (the Overhaul notes they specifically eat the flesh of intelligent creatures). This would be an interesting moral dilemma for the PCs; would they be willing to ally with the ghouls, in the interest of taking out a “worse” faction of non-undead creatures?

#31: Dragon Turtle. The dragon turtle fills the same well-populated sea monster niche as the sea serpent and giant tentacled things, although it has a bit more flair (steam breath, mistaken for an island). But we planned for this. 

Most of the Monster Overhaul covers the classic monsters one would expect in a fantasy RPG; goblins, dragons, zombies, normal humans. But I appreciate that the book also found room for unique creations of the blogging world, and the dragon turtle entry gives us an excuse to use one of them: the tortoise tsar.

This is a coal-eating, serf-oppressing turtle who eats coal. It is easy to imagine him ending up in prison. Over an IRL year ago, we learned that our fire elemental was summoned by the tsar, so he currently has some power within the prison. He’s currently scheming to get (1. more coal (2. more peasants and (3. his freedom. Tsar Yuri VIII has 11 peasants, listless and unmotivated, probably inmates he has recruited. He is noisily venting excess steam pressure and demanding tolls for passage. He probably controls a chokepoint in the dungeon, where he can use the steam to heat a metal passage or bridge to a dangerously hot temperature for anyone who refuses to pay his tolls. 




Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Using the Game of Telephone to Obscure RPG Lore

The classic game of telephone (also known as “whispers” in some countries) is simple; a message is transmitted from person to person by whispering. The final message is humorously different from the original. The game scales in difficulty with the number of participants, as the message degrades further as it passes through additional imperfect transmitters. This simple game can also serve as a model for how information decays over time in a TTRPG.

We don’t need a group's help to apply the telephone game logic to an RPG. We can just use a free translation service. Yes, the same “translate language X to Y to Z and then back to X” game that became popular in the internet of the late 2000s can be used as a game design tool.

Consider a simple rubric like this for mysterious ancient lore that PCs might encounter in a fantasy game.

Mostly intact: The information is current, or very well preserved. It may be slightly obscured or jumbled. Maybe someone made a mistake, or wrote it down quickly, but it is still close to the original content. Translate to at least one foreign language, then back to your native language.

Old and misremembered: A strong sense of the information is there, but specific details and pieces have been lost. The gaps probably don’t entirely obscure the core of the message, but the information is decidedly incomplete. Translate through at least two foreign languages, then back to your native language.

Ancient and obscure: Many core concepts are preserved, but some are lost, and even the intact parts have scrambled details, or can no longer be fully understood. Translate through at least three foreign languages, then back to your native language.

Inscrutable nonsense: The information’s fundamental meaning has been almost completely lost. What remains is not much better than nothing at all. Absent great effort, the information is useless gibberish. Translate through at least four foreign languages, then back to your native language.

You may have to experiment with the number of languages required to get a suitably scrambled message, hence the “at least” qualifier above. Some languages produce stronger or weaker distortions. Add more steps until it feels right.





An Example: Ó̵̢̪̤̰̍ͅp̶̡̝̈́͐̊̇͝e̶̢̤̪͚̾͜n̷̪̖̺̼̣͛͝ ̸͈̜͎̞̝̾̿S̴̥̰̤̝͑ë̴̳̲̩̺́̇́̂͑s̴̨̺̥̟̲͂̏̓͠͝a̷̭͉̝̋m̶̭͉̼̥͊́͋e̶͒ͅ 

A magical door within the dungeon only opens when the following words are recited: “wrack and ruin, who gods abhor, lord of strife, open the door.” This information is written down somewhere nearby, or partially known to someone within the dungeon, but the information is degraded. 

Mostly intact (translated from English to Amharic, then back to English): “Destruction and destruction, abomination to the gods, Lord of hatred, open the door.”

You can see that this is almost correct. In this form it might work the majority of the time, or perhaps the door opens, but only after a delay. 

Old and misremembered (translated from English to Russian to Balinese to English): “Destruction and death, hated by the gods, disobedient lords, open the door.”

This message has drifted a bit further from the original meaning. It is now less clear who is being petitioned. Lord has inadvertently been pluralized to lords. This probably won’t work as-is. The door might shudder and shift slightly, but not open until the message is closer to the original instruction.  

Ancient and obscure (translated from English to Ukrainian to Gujarati to Hakha Chin to English): “God-hated destruction and destruction open the door, warlord.”

This message retains some of the original sense; we can tell it is still about opening the door. But beyond that, it is pretty unclear. Is destruction bad or good in this context? Is the “warlord” the petitioner, or the petitionee? There are useful clues, but these words as-is aren’t going to open this magic door. 

Inscrutable nonsense (translated from English to Urdu to French to Galician to Bambara to Albanian to Javanese to English): “Destroy and annihilate, what the Lord hates, O God, reveal.”

It took a few extra translations, but this message is now even more distorted. It doesn’t even mention the door at all. It has only the faintest traces of the source message. 

What Are the PCs Supposed to Do with the DM’s Inscrutable Nonsense 

OK, that was fun. But what are the PCs supposed to do with this?

I would not obfuscate what is going on here. Strongly hint or outright say that the information has been degraded from its original form, and reversing that process will get them what they want; whether that is literal magic words, as in the above example, or something more prosaic, like clear directions to a secret location. 

The most straightforward way to allow PCs to make progress is to simply move them one step down the obfuscation ladder. The PCs could make progress through intrinsic means (e.g., a PC makes a skill roll for a history or lore ability) or through extrinsic methods (e.g., after exploring the dungeon further, they find a better version of the information that is more complete and less degraded).

Regardless, when they make progress, upgrade the message one step, for example, from “inscrutable nonsense” to “ancient and obscure.” Make it clear that the new answer is probably more accurate than the last one, even if that isn’t obvious from the degree of sense inherent in the message. Clever players may be able to cross reference the differences to try to infer the actual meaning. If they get stuck, they can always search for more answers that clarify what they’re looking for, all the way up to moving a “mostly intact” message up to a completely correct one. 

The World's Largest Rewrite: The First and Probably Last Rhinoceros-Based Fire Suppression System

What is this? The whole series is here , and the first post explaining what is going on is here .  #111: Spectre. The spectre is just a tan...