What is this? The whole series is here, and the first post explaining what is going on is here.
#111: Spectre. The spectre is just a tankier wraith. It has been a rough couple of decades for the spectres. As of 5E, they've been demoted to the low-challenge-rating spawn that wraiths spit out when they drain someone to death.
We can use the Monster Overhaul’s catch-all ghost category to expand our spectres. They cannot cross running water, or objects painted to resemble water. So water, routed by the gargoyles, is used to contain them. They’re prisoners here because no one knows how to banish them.
#96: Rhagodessa. Archanids with suckers on their legs that grab prey to set up an automatic bite on the next turn. We can return to the giant spider Overhaul entry again to spice these up. One of the stranger spider variants there are crafting spiders, with “human hands, pale human-like faces. As smart as most people, but fickle and ascetic.” The dungeon has plenty of monstrous animals, so adding another intelligent creature as a prisoner type is appealing.
#13: Buccaneer. The buccaneer stat block itself is not interesting; they are essentially the same as many of the other 1 HD humans we’ve already covered. As with many of those other human stat blocks, the entry is primarily a tool for creating a wilderness/town faction, moreso than stats for a dungeon encounter.
Rolling there, we get four small galleys patrolling the coastal waters, each crewed by 20 buccaneers. A couple 4th level lieutenants are present; each ship is captained by a 7th level fighter; and we have a fleet commander who is a 9th level fighter. They also have an 8th-level cleric. They have maps to buried treasure and have a lawless, fortified pirate haven nearby.
The Overhaul gives us extra detail to work with. The ships are named The Venture, Spearheart, Aurora, and The Albatross. Several have seen better times, but the fleet commander’s ship is freshly painted. They seek the seaglass staff, a legendary piratical artifact. The fleet commander is Reginald Hooke, who has an “untrustworthy parrot”! Clearly a spy for the octopus cult. Their cleric is Godeke Dire, who plays the fiddle.
#125: Tyrannosaurus Rex. This rounds out the lost world theme. The stat block is what you would expect. The most interesting thing there is that they have treasure type “V x 3”; the only other creature with that treasure type is the noble. Is this a joke, referencing that the t-rex as the “king” of dinosaurs? The Overhaul gives a save-or-die on a bite dealing more than 10 damage, which is a nice way to drive home its deadliness.
#91: Pirate. Statistically almost identical to buccaneers, but chaotic instead of neutral. This group has five small galleys with 40 crew each. We also have a whole mess of 4th and 5th level pirates, and two 8th-level pirates leading the fleet. Those leaders are Khadiga (flat pancake face) and Essafah (stump-fingered). The pirates outnumber the buccaneers, but their two leaders are vying for control of the fleet, and regularly try to betray each other, so they aren't unified enough to wipe out their bucaneer rivals. All of these pirates and buccaneers are drawn here by legends suggesting that the seaglass staff is held within the prison dungeon. Whether this is true or is merely octopus cult propaganda remains to be seen.
#118: Titanothere. Huge, peaceful, lost world rhinoceros relatives. The Overhaul directs us to rhinoceros, which thankfully has a legendary abilities table. It is troubled by parasites, and cleaning its skin is the only way to get the normally peaceful creatures to calm down and stop trampling people.
#8: Berserker. The Overhaul’s barbarian entry does double duty here. These berserkers can break weapons or shatter armor as a feat of strength. They want rare beasts, which explains why they would be in the prison, to seek out those lost world beasts. They are led by Tunbeard, who collects unusual teeth. Fits with the “rare beasts” hobby.
This group has the opposite temperament of our barbarians. As with buccaneers and pirates, the easiest way to create separation between synonyms is to make them rivals or ideological foes.
#44: Giant. The same canonical big six that appear in modern D&D. The Overhaul splits them into giants (hill, stone, as well as giantkin like the ettin and cyclops) and noble giants (storm, cloud, frost, fire, and some stranger examples). There’s even an entry for boneless giants, which must be a reference to Deep Carbon Observatory.
The Overhaul’s “Why Fight These Giants” table tells us they “roasted our best diplomat alive.” That suggests a prisoner. Rolling some more, we get a forest giant, mossy, with antlers. Perhaps a forest guardian, associated with our treants and dryads atop the prison. And the diplomat was the celestial representative who first came to bargain over the opening of the prison. And their death made the forest giant one of the very first inmates.
#97: Rhinoceros. Both normal and wooly varieties, and the latter is a lost world resident. But distinct from a Titanothere! Somehow! Surely this bestiary needed two ancient rhinoceros-type creatures. For some reason.
We return to the Overhaul’s rhinoceros entry. I appreciate how the Overhaul handles several of the ordinary beasts by giving them “legendary” abilities. These could be literal abilities in a high-magic game; or the mark of a paragon of that animal type; or merely local rumors that serve as hooks and detail for the setting. This gives some depth to entries that otherwise boil down to “use bears plus poison/charge/swallow/etc.” for many real-world animals.
Rolling there, we learn that a rhinoceros “tramples out fires wherever they [find] them, not from fear but from duty.” That’s unexpected. We’ve already discussed the problem of fire in the dungeon, particularly because the glass hounds starting invisible fires. A rhinoceros can smell those fires and put them out before they spread. They’re here to help. That just might not be obvious to a terrified party when a rhinoceros fire brigade comes barreling down a dungeon corridor.
#128: Veteran. Completing the PC-classes-as-monster-entries, the veterans are low-level fighters, presumably soldiers. Returning to the Overhaul’s mercenary entry, we see that they have a “false reputation for cruelty.” They can’t fight today because “the enemy made us a better offer.” So they’re traitors. Against who? Remember that the orcs are on their way to trash the prison. These veterans have been hired to fight the orcs, but have decided (probably correctly) that whoever has commissioned them isn’t a good bet to actually pay, and they’re better off finding a way to get rich quick before the orcs arrive.
The end is near. One more post wraps up this series.








