Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Taste-Testing D&D Potion Identification Methods

Potions are the “most accessible” magic items in the world of fantasy RPGs. Holy revengers, staves of powerfulness, and hammers of the dwarvensort are limited to particular types of characters. But anyone – from a veteran adventurer to the lowliest hireling to a Victorian girl lost in a wondrous land – can drink a mysterious liquid and just see what happens.

How PCs determine what exactly a potion does is a vague-gestures-and-shrugs exercise for some dungeon fantasy systems. The 5E (2014) DMG says that “...a little taste is enough to tell the taster what the potion does.” OSE is more guarded, stating that “A potion may be identified by sipping a small amount. It is difficult to identify potions purely by smell or taste, as even potions with the same effect are not alike.” Worlds Without Number has a few layers of possible interpretation wrapped around the taste-test-as-clue rule. Knave 2E keeps it simple: “A drop of a potion gives a clue as to its effects.” The AD&D DMG gives a typically adversarial framing, suggesting that the DM should “add a few different sorts of potions, both helpful and harmful, of such nature as to cause difficulties in identification.”

A 5E potion is a resource. An OSE potion is a risk. A WWN potion is a downtime skill challenge. A Knave potion is a mystery. An AD&D potion is a challenge.


An animated gif displaying eight brightly colored potions, bubbling and vibrating with obvious magical energy

How can we make potions a puzzle that preserve mystery but reward experimentation and attention to detail? Consider a list of 20 typical fantasy potions, with textures and colors drawn from Knave 2E’s random tables.

Potion of Animal Friendship Churning Salmon
Potion of Clairvoyance Churning Dove Gray
Potion of Darkvision Flakes Dove Gray
Potion of Delusion Flakes Dove Gray
Potion of Diminution Sediment Dove Gray
Potion of Fire Resistance Sediment Salmon
Potion of Flying Viscid Electric Blue
Potion of Gaseous Form Bubbling Moss Green
Potion of Giant Strength Flakes Moss Green
Potion of Growth Viscid Moss Green
Potion of Healing Churning Salmon
Potion of Heroism Churning Salmon
Potion of Invisibility Sediment Opalescent
Potion of Madness Bubbling Electric Blue
Potion of Petrification Flakes Opalescent
Potion of Poison Viscid Moss Green
Potion of Speed Bubbling Electric Blue
Potion of Stone Skin Sediment Opalescent
Potion of Transformation Viscid Opalescent
Potion of Water Breathing Bubbling Electric Blue

Some textures and colors seem to communicate the vibe of a particular potion clearly. Some combinations are unique. Others appear to be the same, but are not. Of course the viscid, moss-green potion is poison… but it could also be a potion of growth.

Players can engage with this as a gamble (drink it and see what happens) or as a puzzle (can we infer things about its nature by where it was found) or as a goal (we can spend money in town to have the alchemist identify these with certainty). 

Knave 2E has a rule that succeeding on a check by 10 or more to create a potion provides a recipe and eliminates the need for further checks. The same sort of logic could apply to potion identification; clear a certain threshold, whether mechanical or diegetic, and the "mystery" of a particular potion's nature is not interesting any more; just give PCs the information after that point. 

The table above is a deliberately light touch, but you could be more formulaic about it if you want to emphasize challenge and mystery. This could absolutely be a logic grid puzzle, where color aligns with school of magic and taste aligns with effect. Assuming certain combinations have fixed meanings, the PCs could intuit the nature of unknown potions as they experiment with the ones they have already found. How much formulaic rigor we want to apply depends on the players’ interest in engaging with these factors, and how central potions are to our game.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The 3x3 Language Grid: Dialect, Formal, Technical; Spoken, Written, Symbolic

The 3x3 alignment grid has a certain elegance to it. While I do not like the good-evil axis of D&D’s traditional grid, I appreciate the ...